← All articles

We have been scammed: the first 24 hours

I have written a lot here about spotting these things coming: the video call that was not him, the supplier's cloned voice, the flawless email with not one typo. What is missing is the part nobody wants to need and plenty of people end up needing: what you do once you realise it has already happened.

And here the difference is not made by how sophisticated the scam was. It is made by the clock. Money from a transfer can be stopped while it is still in transit; a few hours later it has usually hopped to a second account and the trail gets very hard to follow.

The 30-second version

First: how you find out

These things rarely arrive with a label on them. The usual signals that something has gone wrong:

If you see one, do not wait until you are certain. Act as though it is real; you can always stand it down afterwards.

Hour 0 to 1: stop the bleeding

Hour 1 to 4: preserve the evidence

The instinct is to delete the scam email out of sheer anger. Do not: it is your evidence.

Take screenshots with the date visible, and keep the original messages without forwarding them — forwarding strips technical headers that investigators do use. Write down in a single document the destination account, the amounts, the dates and times, the phone numbers, and who authorised each step. Then check whether there are further payments queued to the same account, and stop them.

Hour 4 to 24: report and communicate

A concrete case

An accountancy firm in Terrassa received an email from its IT supplier with a change of bank account and an invoice for €8,400. The email was impeccable: same signature, same tone, same conversation thread. They paid at 10 a.m. on a Thursday.

At 10:40 the office administrator called the supplier about something else and it came up. Immediate call to the bank: €5,900 that had not yet moved was frozen. The rest was gone. Forty minutes was worth almost six thousand euros.

Four things not to do

And the following week

Two simple measures prevent the large majority of these cases. First: no change of bank account details is ever accepted by email — it is verified by calling the number you already had, never the one in the message. Second: two-factor authentication on mail and on anything that moves money.

Neither is a technology project. Both are a rule somebody has to own, which is the part that usually does not happen.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reporting routes and supervisory authorities vary by country; the ones named here are the Spanish ones. For a specific decision with legal consequences, consult a qualified lawyer.

About this article

iaetica.cat is a space for writing in the open: what I am learning about artificial intelligence, its ethics and its law.

— Laura Graells